Thanking a donor or member within 24 to 48 hours is worth a one-month test, because speed may change what they give next.
Most nonprofits and associations treat the donor thank-you as a formality to finish before moving to the next task. Here is the spark: what if the time it takes to send that thank-you is the variable worth testing, not just the wording?
Why This Is Worth Testing
Penelope Burk of Cygnus Applied Research, known for her donor-centered fundraising studies, found that a thank-you call from a board member to a newly acquired donor within 24 hours increased that donor’s next gift by 39 percent, according to findings reported by Bloomerang. That is a large swing attached to a single variable: how quickly the thank-you happens, not how elaborate it is.
Burk made the underlying point in an interview with NonprofitPRO, where she described an excellent thank-you letter as “your first step in cultivating the next gift.” The thank-you is not the end of a transaction. It is the start of the next one, and speed appears to be part of what makes it land.
The evidence is not one-sided. The same Bloomerang article notes a 2019 study that found thank-you calls “made no difference at all.” Bloomerang also reports that critics question that study’s design: the calls were outsourced to a call center, so no one connected to the organization made them. That is one more reason to test who sends the thank-you, not only how fast.
What This Means in Practice
Most nonprofits and associations already send a thank-you. The test here is not whether to thank a donor or member. It is how fast, and who does it. A form letter that arrives three weeks later carries a different weight than a short call or handwritten note that arrives the same week, even when the words are similar.
Try This Yourself
For one month, pick a group of new or renewing donors or members and commit to a thank-you within 24 to 48 hours of their gift or renewal, by phone where you have a number, or by a short personal email or handwritten note where you do not. Keep the message itself close to what you already send. Change only the timing and, where possible, who sends it: a board member or the executive director rather than an automated system. Compare the next-gift or renewal rate for that group against a comparable group thanked on your normal timeline.
Some ideas will work, some will not. A phone call might land well with a longtime donor and feel intrusive to a first-time one who gave anonymously online. Watch for that difference as you test, not just the overall number.
Why This Matters More for a Lean Team
A large nonprofit or association can staff a stewardship team that calls every donor within a day as standard practice. A small and mid-size business, an association, or a nonprofit with one person covering marketing, communications, and half of operations usually cannot promise a personal thank-you within a day on every gift, sale, or renewal. What that person can do is pick one segment, such as new donors or new members in a single month, and test the 24-hour window on that group alone before deciding whether it is worth building into the regular process.
Start Here
Pick one group of donors or members for the next month. Commit to thanking them within 24 to 48 hours, by a person rather than a system where you can manage it. Compare what they give or renew next against your usual pace.
If you want a wider look at your retention marketing first, the Marketing Assessment is a good place to start. Have an idea you want tested? Book a free 30-minute marketing strategy reset and bring it with you.
Sources
- Call Donors to Thank Them and Boost Future Donations (Bloomerang, reporting Penelope Burk’s research)
- “Thank You” Done Right Goes a Long Way (NonprofitPRO, interview with Penelope Burk)